‘Til the Cows Come Home: Local Youth Program Aids in Resolution for Dispute Between Federal Agency and Cattlemen’s Association

A dispute between a local Cattlemen’s Association and a federal agency has been mitigated by students — more specifically, a summer youth work program called the Clearwater Basin Youth Conservation Corps.

Cattle near Elk Creek Meadows
Cattle near Elk Creek Meadows

“Cows go where cows go,” says the Mason Butte Cattlemen’s Association President Roy Busch, as he describes the longstanding issues of free-range cattle roaming onto recreational land managed by the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers (USACE) in Ahsahka, Idaho, near the Dworshak Dam. “They have a fence line that they put in back when they constructed the dam in the ‘70s, and for the last few years they haven’t done anything with the fence.”

Contention between state and federal land management issues are nothing new in Idaho, with public lands covering over 80% of the state. “The issue with cattle trespassing on Corps of Engineers managed lands didn’t develop overnight, and it’s not going to be solved overnight,” says USACE Natural Resource Manager Paul Pence, explaining that the fence line between the two pieces of land divides cattle grazing land and recreational sites. Due to the broken fencing in certain areas, cows can wander through campsites, through habitat development areas, and down to the water’s edge.

The primary boundary fences that serve as the source of contention between the USACE and the Cattlemen’s association were installed and maintained by the Corps until the year 2000. Budget cuts and reduction in labor force have limited recreation dollars for projects such as fencing upkeep. Grazing on Federal land requires a permit, and without one, these cows could be considered trespassing, causing their owners to be cited with tickets and fines.

Idaho open range law [Idaho Code 25-2118] states that cows are permitted to roam, but Federal law requires a permit to graze on Federal lands. This point of contention is another example of how discrepancies form between government and the private sector.

USACE Lead Ranger Gus Garbe oversees fence building by Orofino CBYCC Crew Members Malachi Kirk and Christian Norman
USACE Lead Ranger Gus Garbe oversees fence building by Orofino CBYCC Crew Members Malachi Kirk and Christian Norman

Despite the often contentious relationship between the Mason Butte Cattlemen’s Association and the USACE, both parties look for solutions.

“Along comes YCC,” says Paul Pence. He details that at one of the Cattlemen’s Association meetings, he pitched the idea of having the Clearwater Basin Youth Conservation Corps (CBYCC) assist in rebuilding the fence line.

Pence asked Busch to point out the problem areas with the fence line that have been the source of the issue. “Not only will we supply materials, we’ll come out there with a crew of kids, and we’re going to help fix this fence and try and get it stood up. That’ll help solve the problem for both of us.”

The CBYCC employs youth between the ages of 16 and 18 for eight weeks each summer in order to prepare North-Central Idaho youth for a career in natural resources. Students work on projects from trail maintenance to wildlife habitat restoration, and work with a variety of state and federal agencies, such as the U.S. Forest Service and the USACE.

The Mason Butte Cattlemen’s Association sent ranchers and range riders out this past summer to teach the CBYCC students how to repair and rebuild fence. Of the 5.2 miles of fencing, about 2 miles that surround Elk Creek Meadows have been completed.

USACE Lead Ranger Gus Garbe oversaw the site work performed by the students of the CBYCC. “[The students] are doing a great job. Fencing is tough, unless you grow up doing it all your life like these ranchers have,” says Garbe. He also adds, “A big thank you to Mason Butte for coming out and helping us out, and the Clearwater Basin Youth Conservation Corps.”

The 2018 Orofino CBYCC Crew after completing 2 miles of fence. From left; Malachi Kirk, Arden Rueben, Jacob Strahan, Christian Norman, Samuel Naden.
The 2018 Orofino CBYCC Crew after completing 2 miles of fence. From left; Malachi Kirk, Arden Rueben, Jacob Strahan, Christian Norman, Samuel Naden.

The fencing project is slated to continue for the 2019 summer season. For more information about the Clearwater Basin Youth Conservation Corps, visit clearwaterbasincollaborative.org/cbycc and facebook.com/IdahoCBYCC.


The Clearwater RC&D assists many bourgeoning collaborative groups and organizations throughout the region through fiscal sponsorship, an arrangement allowing groups such as the CBYCC to obtain grants and donations under a sponsor’s nonprofit status. This leaves the heavy paperwork, regulations, and requirements to the Clearwater RC&D, so individuals and organizations can focus on their projects.  To learn more about the Clearwater Resource Conservation and Development Council and whether fiscal sponsorship could benefit your project or organization, contact Barbie Miller, Executive Director, at (208) 883-4471 or visit clearwaterrcd.org.

 

Leave a Reply

Close Menu